Welcome to Gaetano’s of West Berlin
Gaetano's of West Berlin is a vibrant eatery that brings a slice of Italian-American tradition to New Jersey. This veteran-owned establishment specializes in mouthwatering cheesesteaks, pizzas, and Italian dishes, all crafted with fresh ingredients. Diners are greeted with a casual, family-friendly atmosphere that welcomes guests of all ages. From the satisfying crunch of their wings to the generous portions of their famous Jersey Steak, every dish is a testament to quality and flavor. With options like vegetarian fare and customized takeout, Gaetano’s ensures everyone enjoys a memorable meal. Dining here is more than just a meal; it's an experience you’ll want to repeat.
Gaetano’s of West Berlin: Reviews & Ratings
My husband and I ordered because we haven't had a good cheesesteak. We ordered a Ham and cheese small, a garlic bread cheesesteak large, and pepperoni cheesesteak large with loaded cheese fries. Service and food was outstanding!! The energy is awesome and our takeout was definitely 10 minutes as the sweet lady advised us. We will definitely visit again!!
This review is from my mom. She is of the boomer era so she doesn't understand the point of Yelp, but after our most recent order she was sending pics, talked about it for days, and insisted I post. The wings were the best price around and BIG BOIs. I personally was impressed with how crunchy they were! Blue cheese and ranch both tasted homemade and made well. American Hoagie was made perfectly. Salad was fresh and huge. Overall very pleased with my order and the service!!
Amazing food at fair prices and friendly staff. The pizza is chefs kiss! Will definitely be back again!
Nothing beats a Gaetano's Jersey Steak (loaded with meat, potatoes, onions and A-1 sauce) on a soft seeded roll! I'll take this over Jim's, Pat's OR Gino's in Philly any day! Great thing is that it's not soaking in grease at all...always tastes fresh! They make a pretty good salad loaded with ham and cheese too!
Amazing cheesesteak! One of the best in South Jersey by far! Very nice staff as well.
Never had the wings nor pizza so can't speak on them, but this is a cheesesteak place through and through- so that's what you should order. The steaks are a bit on the pricey side but thats totally justified given the amount of meat you get. A 7 inch is all you need unless you want multiple meals, and there's easily a pound of steak in that sandwich. Delicious. Also recommend the old bay fries. This place does a real philly cheese steak better than most in south jersey.
Location
-
437 Rt 73 N Ste 437 West Berlin, NJ 08091 United States Hotline: (856) 753-1919
Welcome to the delicious world of Gaetano’s of West Berlin, a standout gem in the realm of comfort food! Located at 437 Rt 73 N Ste 437, West Berlin, NJ, this veteran-owned establishment specializes in mouthwatering cheesesteaks, flavorful pizzas, and authentic Italian dishes. Its welcoming atmosphere and commitment to quality make it a fantastic choice for families, friends, and anyone craving hearty meals in a casual setting.
Gaetano’s shines with its diverse menu; whether you're after a classic cheesesteak loaded with savory ingredients or a fresh, colorful salad, there's something for everyone. The reviews are in, and patrons rave about the Jersey Steak, generously piled with meat, potatoes, onions, and a zesty A-1 sauce, served on a perfectly soft seeded roll. Enthusiasts also can't get enough of the crispy wings served with a side of homemade blue cheese and ranch, making for unforgettable finger food.
- Highlights:
- ???? Conveniently available for takeout and delivery for those cozy nights in!
- ???? Offers many vegetarian options ensuring all palettes are satisfied.
- ????️ Perfect for group gatherings with its casual yet vibrant dining space.
- ???? Notable culinary value with happy hour specials that won't break the bank!
- ???? Dog-friendly outdoor seating, allowing you to bring along your furry companions.
With its moderate noise level and inviting atmosphere, it’s an ideal spot for dinner with friends or a family meal. The restaurant keeps the environment friendly and casual, ensuring you feel right at home while enjoying your meal. Plus, with amenities like free Wi-Fi, OUTDOOR HEATED seating, and bike parking, it's clear they care about their patrons' experiences beyond just the food.
The reviews from happy customers speak volumes: Terri B. described her experience as "outstanding" while recommending a variety of cheesesteaks, and David M. boldly claims Gaetano’s is better than the renowned establishments in Philadelphia. These glowing endorsements highlight the restaurant's dedication to freshness and quality, making each dish a delightful experience.
In summary, Gaetano’s of West Berlin isn't just about meals; it's about bringing people together over delicious food. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite on the go, gathering for a group celebration, or simply treating yourself to some of the best cheesesteaks in South Jersey, you can expect a warm welcome and an exceptional culinary journey. Don’t forget to call ahead at (856) 753-1919 to reserve your spot or place your order!
